bridgeburner18
05-08-2009, 12:20 PM
So for those of you who have seen the movie so far... rate it, overall and on sections. DO NOT DISCUSS PLOT DETAILS.
also how awesome do you think STO will be in comparison?
Plot: 7 of 10, not bad, not great average overall just to introduce and start the charectors.
Effects: 9.5 of 10, some of the best graphic details and effects i have seen in any movie, let alone a trek movie.
Sound: 9.5 of 10, sound effects were excellent, i found myself getting anxious right before the sound hit when they jumped to warp, but a different take on it, very suspensful.
Cast: 8.5 of 10, a tough rating because you had some really memorable performances and some really flat ones, my personal fav was suprisingly spock, syler did a good job with the role, personal dislike was aurora, didn't care for the whoel im hot thing.
True to Fans: 7 of 10, again a tough rating only because we knew this would be a "new" trek, setting that aside their were some familiar nods and some homages to us the fans but overall it was a very "different" trek.
Overall: 8.3 rating. Great film very fun and overall enjoyable with some suprising moments of humour. Sadly it is a departure from normal trek but perhaps that is a good thing as i can see this film will be very successful thus the franchise will be successful and maybe we can see trek on the small screen again soon.
STO: very awesome.
(Edited to make thread game related...)
also how awesome do you think STO will be in comparison?
Plot: 7 of 10, not bad, not great average overall just to introduce and start the charectors.
Effects: 9.5 of 10, some of the best graphic details and effects i have seen in any movie, let alone a trek movie.
Sound: 9.5 of 10, sound effects were excellent, i found myself getting anxious right before the sound hit when they jumped to warp, but a different take on it, very suspensful.
Cast: 8.5 of 10, a tough rating because you had some really memorable performances and some really flat ones, my personal fav was suprisingly spock, syler did a good job with the role, personal dislike was aurora, didn't care for the whoel im hot thing.
True to Fans: 7 of 10, again a tough rating only because we knew this would be a "new" trek, setting that aside their were some familiar nods and some homages to us the fans but overall it was a very "different" trek.
Overall: 8.3 rating. Great film very fun and overall enjoyable with some suprising moments of humour. Sadly it is a departure from normal trek but perhaps that is a good thing as i can see this film will be very successful thus the franchise will be successful and maybe we can see trek on the small screen again soon.
STO: very awesome.
(Edited to make thread game related...)